With Rise of Iron, Destiny feels like a game thatís within reach of fresh ideas, but canít quite escape its own past. There are moments of exhilaration throughout the newest expansion, and a few inspiring missions remain rooted in my memory, but as Bungieís shooter wades into its third year, a sense of fatigue has risen to the surface. Destinyís exhaustion is beginning to show.

From a story standpoint, Rise of Iron follows our Guardians as they assist Lord Saladin, one of the last remaining members of the Iron Lords, in his fight against Siva, a nanobot plague that all but exterminated his group years before present events. Rise of Iron borrows its aesthetic from fantasy tales such as Lord of the Rings and Game of Thrones, pulling us up to the snowy Felwinter Peak to the sound of low horns and loud clarion calls. At its outset, Rise of Iron displays a confident sense of character.

But that wears thin soon thereafter. Destinyís new campaign lasts for about 90 minutes, and while it does a decent job of setting up the expansionís late-game missions and public events, the plot serves only to introduce us to new quest-givers and areas of interest. Any narrative promise the opening moments display soon fades. The campaignís final boss battle may be thrilling--it encourages frantic melee combat against an onslaught of enemies--but the short trip it takes to get there is forgettable
As a major Destiny expansion, of course, Rise of Iron also brings additional cooperative strikes, public events, player vs. player options, a new social space, a new patrol zone, and a six-player raid. I call this content additional, and not new, for a reason: much of Rise of Ironís content is taken from Destinyís first two years and given a fresh coat of paint.
Click image for larger version. 

Name:	3134928-3111243-roi_strike_wretchedeye_3rdp_09.jpg 
Views:	96 
Size:	32.5 KB 
ID:	17058
Yes, Siva-infected enemies bring new dangers to firefights, and existing bosses have changed their combat strategy to make things just fresh enough to initially feel different. But the Destiny grind is more apparent here than ever. Iím once again firing round after round into Sepiks Prime. Iím patrolling the snowy wilderness on a strikingly familiar Earth. Iím wading through strikes Iíve played dozens of times before. The Wretched Eye strike, Rise of Ironís truly new cooperative venture, is one of the aforementioned shining moments. But itís surrounded by vapid echoes of the past.

Rise of Ironís player vs. player content follows suit. The new Supremacy game mode requires you to pick up fallen orbs from slain enemies, not granting you full credit for a kill until you do so. You can also deny opponents their points by collecting your comradesí telltale remains--the system creates tense situations as players rush into the open to gather orbs, only to die and make the field that much more tantalizing for the next challenger. Smart players can hang back and pick off scavengers shortly before gathering several points for themselves.

While Supremacy does lure you out of your comfort zone with enticing scenarios, the experience is only a slight variation on the classic deathmatch formula. As with Rise of Ironís campaign, Supremacy feels uninspired. Rise of Ironís maps are well designed, combining close-quarters battles and long-range engagements with seeming ease, proving once again that studio Bungie is a top-tier developer of competitive shooter arenas. But these maps set the stage for a new mode that doesnít pull its own creative weight.

The redundancies in Destiny's campaign, strikes, and Crucible content are a shame, too, considering the moments of greatness Rise of Iron does deliver.

The redundancies in Destinyís campaign, strikes, and Crucible content are a shame, too, considering the moments of greatness Rise of Iron does deliver. The quest line to obtain the newest version of Gjallahorn, Destinyís now-mythical rocket launcher, culminates in a massive battle the likes of which Bungie hasnít created since its Halo days. Archonís Forge, the expansionís new public event space, plays host to chaotic battles between a possible nine players and a variety of alien bosses. The sheer spectacle of these skirmishes combines with Destinyís mechanical fluidity to create some of the shooterís finest moments to date.

This rings true in Rise of Ironís Wrath of the Machine raid. The trek pits you and five other players against an array of enemies in a bevy of complex scenarios that donít use boss battles and hordes of enemies as crutches.

While these elements are present, Wrath of the Machine demands that you rethink what a boss fight can be: without spoiling too much, one section of the raid asks you not just to battle a massive enemy, but use it as transportation, too. Wrath of the Machineís final encounter is one of those shining moments I keep coming back to. Despite the difficulty youíll encounter, itís a stunning combination of teamwork, survival techniques, and combat tactics, as well as using the expansionís pervasive Siva against itself, that will carry your squad through.
Click image for larger version. 

Name:	3134929-3111247-roi_strike_wretchedeye_env_03.jpg 
Views:	96 
Size:	26.4 KB 
ID:	17059
But the raid is the sparkling light at the end of an often-dreary tunnel. I spent dozens of hours slogging through familiar strikes, uninspired new Crucible content, and a patrol zone that felt like a retread, not an adventure. I found myself playing more for the new gear and Light levels--for the progress--than the actual enjoyment.

As an expansion that revamped how Destiny actually played, last yearís The Taken King was a major step forward for the shooter. But Rise of Iron feels merely like the other foot catching up to rest firmly in place. It feels timid. It feels safe. It feels like the last remaining breath before the possible sequel, as if Destiny is standing still and waiting for inspiration to arrive, rather than going out to find it.